Comparison

Pataday vs Zaditor: Which Allergy Eye Drop Is Better?

Photo of author

By Health Linear Editorial Team

Updated

Two eye drop bottles above an eye silhouette, one trailing a long sun arc representing Pataday and one a shorter arc representing Zaditor

Pataday (olopatadine) and Zaditor (ketotifen) are over-the-counter eye drops for itchy eyes caused by allergies. Both block histamine and stabilize the mast cells that release it. The main practical difference is dosing: Pataday Once Daily Relief and Pataday Extra Strength are used once a day, while Zaditor is used twice a day.

  • Pataday: olopatadine, available as Twice Daily Relief (0.1%), Once Daily Relief (0.2%) and Extra Strength (0.7%). The once-daily versions are labeled for ages 2 and up.
  • Zaditor: ketotifen 0.035% (also sold as Alaway and store brands), 1 drop every 8 to 12 hours, no more than twice a day, ages 3 and up.
  • Effectiveness: both relieve itching within minutes. Some studies favor olopatadine for comfort and longer effect; others find them similar.
  • Contact lenses: take lenses out before using either drop and wait at least 10 minutes before putting them back. Neither treats lens-related irritation.
  • Not for red eyes from infection: these drops treat allergic itch. Pain, discharge, light sensitivity or vision changes need a doctor.

This is general information, not medical advice. See an eye doctor if symptoms last more than 72 hours, get worse, or come with pain or vision changes.

Pataday vs Zaditor at a glance

PatadayZaditor
Active ingredientOlopatadine hydrochlorideKetotifen fumarate
Strengths0.1% (Twice Daily), 0.2% (Once Daily), 0.7% (Extra Strength)0.035% (0.025% ketotifen)
Dose1 drop per eye once daily (0.2% and 0.7%) or twice daily (0.1%)1 drop per eye every 8 to 12 hours, max twice daily
Ages2+ (once daily and extra strength)3+
OTC since20202006
Same drug asPatanol, Pazeo (formerly prescription)Alaway, store-brand ketotifen
OnsetWithin minutesWithin minutes
DurationUp to 24 hours (0.2% and 0.7%)Up to 12 hours

How they work

When pollen, pet dander or dust lands on the eye, mast cells in the conjunctiva release histamine, causing itching, redness, watering and swelling. Both olopatadine and ketotifen:

  • block histamine (H1) receptors, stopping itch quickly
  • stabilize mast cells, reducing the release of histamine and other inflammatory chemicals over time

This dual action makes them more effective for allergic eye itch than older drops that only constrict blood vessels (such as naphazoline in Visine or Naphcon-A), which can cause rebound redness with regular use.

Does one work better?

Several studies have compared them in allergen challenge tests and clinical use:

  • Both reduce itching significantly compared with placebo, starting within minutes.
  • Some studies found olopatadine more comfortable on instillation (less stinging) and favored by more patients.
  • The 0.7% olopatadine (Extra Strength) was developed to last a full 24 hours with one drop, including later in the day when once-daily 0.1% can wear off.

In everyday terms, many people prefer Pataday for the convenience of a single daily drop, while Zaditor and its generics are often cheaper per dose.

How to use allergy eye drops

1. Wash your hands. Remove contact lenses.

2. Tilt your head back and gently pull down your lower eyelid to make a pocket.

3. Squeeze one drop into the pocket without letting the tip touch your eye or lashes.

4. Close your eye gently for a minute and press lightly on the inner corner near the nose to keep the drop in the eye.

5. Repeat in the other eye if needed.

6. Wait at least 10 minutes before putting contacts back in, and 5 minutes before any other eye drops.

Store-chilled drops can feel soothing. Don’t share bottles.

Side effects

Side effectPatadayZaditor
Brief stinging or burningPossiblePossible, sometimes more noticeable
HeadachePossiblePossible
Blurred vision right after useBriefBrief
Dry eyePossiblePossible
Unusual tastePossibleLess common
Red eyes or eyelid swellingUncommonUncommon

Both contain the preservative benzalkonium chloride, which can be absorbed by soft contact lenses. That’s why lenses must be removed before use.

Stop using the drops and see a doctor if you have eye pain, changes in vision, worsening redness, or symptoms lasting more than 72 hours.

Pataday vs Zaditor vs other options

DropIngredientDoseNotes
Pataday Once Daily / Extra StrengthOlopatadine 0.2% / 0.7%Once dailyLongest-acting OTC options
Zaditor, AlawayKetotifen 0.035%Twice dailyUsually least expensive
LastacaftAlcaftadine 0.25%Once dailyOTC since 2023, ages 2+
Visine Allergy, Naphcon-ADecongestant with or without antihistamineUp to 4 times dailyShort-term only; rebound redness with frequent use
Artificial tearsLubricantAs neededRinse allergens out; preservative-free versions available

For people with both itchy eyes and a stuffy nose, a steroid nasal spray such as Flonase (labeled for eye symptoms) or an oral antihistamine can help too. See our guide to Flonase vs Nasacort.

Allergic eye vs other causes

Allergic conjunctivitis typically causes:

  • itching (the hallmark symptom)
  • both eyes affected
  • clear, watery discharge
  • puffy eyelids
  • seasonal pattern or link to pets and dust

See a doctor rather than self-treating if you have:

  • thick yellow or green discharge or crusting (possible infection)
  • one painful red eye
  • sensitivity to light
  • blurred vision that doesn’t clear with blinking
  • a feeling of something stuck in the eye
  • symptoms after an eye injury, or while wearing contact lenses with pain

Frequently asked questions

Is Pataday better than Zaditor?

Both work well for allergic eye itch. Pataday Once Daily and Extra Strength last up to 24 hours with one drop, which many people find more convenient. Zaditor needs two drops a day and is usually cheaper.

Can I use Pataday and Zaditor together?

There’s no benefit to using both. They work in the same way, so pick one.

Can children use Pataday or Zaditor?

Pataday Once Daily Relief and Extra Strength are labeled for ages 2 and up; Zaditor is labeled for ages 3 and up. Ask a doctor for younger children.

Can I wear contact lenses with Pataday or Zaditor?

Remove your lenses before using the drops and wait at least 10 minutes before putting them back in. Don’t use them to treat contact lens irritation.

How quickly do allergy eye drops work?

Both start relieving itch within minutes.

Is Pataday the same as Patanol?

Both contain olopatadine. Patanol (0.1%) and Pataday (0.2%) were prescription drops; they became available over the counter as Pataday Twice Daily Relief and Pataday Once Daily Relief in 2020.

References

About this article

Written by the Health Linear Editorial Team from primary sources such as FDA prescribing information, DailyMed, NIH and peer-reviewed studies, which are linked in the article. Last updated October 30, 2026.

Read our editorial process and medical disclaimer. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.