ADHD, Comparison

Concerta vs Strattera: Effectiveness, Side Effects and Dosing Compared

Photo of author

By Health Linear Editorial Team

Updated

Long white tablet with a sun-to-moon arc beside a capsule with a weekly calendar, comparing Concerta and Strattera

Concerta (extended-release methylphenidate) is a stimulant that works within about an hour and lasts roughly 10 to 12 hours. Strattera (atomoxetine) is a non-stimulant that takes several weeks to reach full effect but then works around the clock. In the largest head-to-head trial in children, more patients responded to Concerta (56%) than to Strattera (45%). A major 2018 analysis of ADHD medicines likewise found methylphenidate more effective than atomoxetine in children, though the two were closer in adults. Strattera’s advantages lie elsewhere. It is not a controlled substance, it has no abuse potential, it is easier to refill, and it doesn’t wear off in the late afternoon. That makes it a strong option when stimulants aren’t suitable.

Below, we compare effectiveness, how each drug works, dosing, side effects, warnings, interactions and combined use, based on the FDA prescribing information and the main comparative studies.

This is general information, not medical advice. Starting, stopping or combining ADHD medicines should be done with the prescriber who manages your or your child’s treatment.

Concerta vs Strattera at a glance

Concerta (methylphenidate ER)Strattera (atomoxetine)
TypeCentral nervous system stimulantNon-stimulant (selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor)
Controlled substanceYes, Schedule IINo
Approved forADHD, ages 6 to 65ADHD, ages 6 and up, including adults
Time to workWithin about an hour of the first doseSome effect in 1 to 2 weeks; full effect often takes 4 to 6 weeks or longer
How long each dose lastsAbout 10 to 12 hoursContinuous, with no daily wear-off once established
How it’s takenOne tablet each morning, swallowed wholeCapsule once daily, or split into morning and late-afternoon doses
Boxed warningAbuse, misuse and addictionSuicidal thoughts in children and teenagers
Main side effectsReduced appetite, trouble sleeping, headache, stomach acheNausea, reduced appetite, tiredness, stomach ache; sexual side effects in adults
Generic availableYesYes

Which works better?

For most children, the evidence favours Concerta.

  • Head-to-head trial: in a six-week double-blind study of 516 children aged 6 to 16 (Newcorn and colleagues, American Journal of Psychiatry, 2008), 56% responded to Concerta and 45% to atomoxetine, against 24% on placebo. Both drugs clearly worked, but Concerta worked for more children. When the Concerta group was then switched to atomoxetine, a notable share of children who had not responded to Concerta did respond to atomoxetine. The drugs help different people, so failing on one doesn’t predict failing on the other.
  • Network meta-analysis: the 2018 Lancet Psychiatry analysis by Cortese and colleagues pooled 133 trials. Methylphenidate came out ahead of atomoxetine in children and adolescents and was recommended as the first-choice medicine for that age group. In adults, atomoxetine’s effect on core symptoms was comparable to methylphenidate’s.
  • Earlier meta-analyses found the advantage applied mainly to long-acting methylphenidate like Concerta. Immediate-release methylphenidate did not clearly beat atomoxetine.

In short, Concerta is the more effective first choice for most children. Strattera is a genuine alternative rather than a weaker fallback, especially for adults, for people who can’t take stimulants, and for people who need all-day coverage.

How each drug works

Concerta contains methylphenidate, which blocks the reuptake of dopamine and norepinephrine, increasing their activity in brain circuits involved in attention and impulse control. What sets Concerta apart from other methylphenidate products is its OROS delivery system. The tablet has an outer coat that releases a small immediate dose, then an osmotic pump that pushes out the rest steadily through a laser-drilled hole over the day. Blood levels rise gradually and peak around 6 to 10 hours after the morning dose. That avoids the peaks and dips of short-acting methylphenidate taken three times a day, and spares children a lunchtime dose at school. The empty tablet shell can pass in the stool, which is normal.

Strattera contains atomoxetine, which blocks norepinephrine reuptake and has little direct effect on dopamine in the brain’s reward pathway. That’s why it isn’t habit-forming and isn’t a controlled substance. Its benefit builds as the brain adapts over weeks, much like an antidepressant, rather than rising and falling with each dose. Once it’s working, there’s no “wearing off” in the evening or early morning, a stretch that stimulants often miss.

Dosing compared

GroupConcertaStrattera
Children 6 to 12Start 18 mg each morning; increase by 18 mg weekly as needed; maximum 54 mgUnder 70 kg: start 0.5 mg/kg/day; after at least 3 days, increase to about 1.2 mg/kg/day; maximum 1.4 mg/kg/day or 100 mg, whichever is less
Teens 13 to 17Start 18 mg; maximum 72 mg (and no more than 2 mg/kg/day)Same weight-based dosing; 70 kg or more uses adult dosing
AdultsStart 18 or 36 mg; maximum 72 mg (ages 18 to 65)Start 40 mg/day; after at least 3 days, increase to 80 mg; maximum 100 mg
TimingMorning, with or without food. Must be swallowed whole, never crushed, chewed or splitMorning, or split into morning and late-afternoon doses; can be taken with or without food (food may reduce nausea)
Strengths18, 27, 36 and 54 mg tablets10, 18, 25, 40, 60, 80 and 100 mg capsules

Strattera capsules shouldn’t be opened. Atomoxetine irritates the eyes, and if powder gets into them, they should be rinsed with water straight away. People who can’t swallow capsules may do better with a different medicine. Our ADHD medication comparison tool filters options by whether they can be sprinkled on food or come as a liquid or chewable.

How quickly each one works

Timeline comparing Concerta working within an hour and fading by evening with Strattera building gradually over several weeks
Concerta works the same day; Strattera builds up over weeks.

With Concerta, an effective dose shows its effect on the first day. Dose finding takes a few weeks only because the dose is stepped up weekly.

Strattera is different. Some improvement may appear in the first one to two weeks, but the full effect usually takes four to six weeks at the target dose, and sometimes longer. The most common mistake is stopping it in week two because “nothing is happening”. If you’re starting Strattera, set a review point at about six weeks at the target dose before judging it.

Side effects compared

Side effectConcertaStrattera
Reduced appetiteCommon, mostly during the dayCommon, often milder
Trouble sleepingCommon, especially if taken lateLess common; tiredness and sleepiness are more typical
Nausea and stomach acheStomach ache is commonCommon, especially early on; taking it with food helps
Heart rate and blood pressureSmall average increasesSmall average increases
MoodIrritability or flatness at higher doses; rebound irritability as it wears offMood changes possible; watch for suicidal thoughts in young people (boxed warning)
Growth in childrenCan slow height and weight gain; growth is monitoredGrowth should also be monitored
Sexual side effects (adults)Less prominentErectile problems, lower libido and trouble urinating are listed in adult trials

Many children on Concerta eat little at lunch and are hungry in the evening. A good breakfast before the dose and a solid dinner and evening snack usually manage this. Both drugs can raise blood pressure and pulse slightly, so both are checked before starting and at follow-up visits.

Boxed warnings and serious risks

The two drugs carry different types of risk, not one big and one small.

  • Concerta’s boxed warning: high potential for abuse and misuse, which can lead to substance use disorder, overdose and death. Risk is higher at higher doses or when the drug is used in ways it wasn’t prescribed. Prescribers are asked to assess abuse risk before starting and to keep tablets secure at home.
  • Strattera’s boxed warning: increased risk of suicidal thoughts in children and teenagers in short-term trials. Families are asked to watch for new or worsening depression, agitation or unusual behaviour, especially in the first few months and after dose changes.
  • Strattera, other serious warnings: rare severe liver injury (stop and get checked for yellow skin or eyes, dark urine, itching or right-sided abdominal pain), and rare prolonged painful erections (priapism), which need urgent care.
  • Both: rare serious heart problems in people with existing heart disease, so a heart history (and family history of sudden death) is taken before starting. Both can also trigger mania in people with bipolar disorder, and can occasionally cause new psychotic symptoms.
  • Concerta only: because the tablet doesn’t dissolve, it should be avoided in people with severe narrowing of the gut. It can also cause circulation problems in the fingers and toes (Raynaud’s phenomenon).

Drug interactions

  • Both: never take either drug with MAO inhibitors, or within 14 days of stopping one.
  • Strattera and CYP2D6 inhibitors: fluoxetine (Prozac), paroxetine (Paxil) and quinidine raise atomoxetine levels several-fold. The label says to start at the usual dose but raise it only after four weeks if needed. Bupropion has a similar effect. About 7% of white people are genetically “poor metabolizers” of CYP2D6, and in them atomoxetine’s half-life stretches from about 5 hours to about 22.
  • Strattera and asthma inhalers: albuterol and similar medicines can increase heart rate and blood pressure more when combined with atomoxetine.
  • Concerta: can reduce the effect of blood pressure medicines. Use with caution alongside other drugs that raise blood pressure.
  • Alcohol: alcohol can worsen side effects with both, can blunt judgment that the medicine is meant to support, and with Strattera adds to any liver strain. See methylphenidate and alcohol and our alcohol and medication interaction checker.

If you take an SSRI alongside either drug, our SSRI comparison tool shows which SSRIs have the strongest interaction profile.

Controlled-substance rules and refills

In the US, Concerta is Schedule II, the strictest category for prescribable medicines. Each fill needs a new prescription (no refills), supply is usually limited to 30 days at a time, and fills are tracked in state prescription monitoring programs. Strattera is not controlled, so it can have refills and longer supplies like most ordinary prescriptions. For families juggling school terms, travel or pharmacy shortages, this practical difference can matter as much as the clinical ones. Strattera is also not affected by the stimulant shortages that have hit methylphenidate and amphetamine products in recent years.

A note on generic Concerta

Generic Concerta must reproduce the OROS release pattern, not just the total dose. In 2014 the FDA found that two early generics did not match Concerta’s release profile closely enough, changed their rating so they were no longer automatically substitutable, and later moved to withdraw them. Generics that meet the revised standard are available. If a switch to a generic seems to change how long or how well the medicine works, tell the prescriber and pharmacist. That’s a known issue, not imagined.

Can Concerta and Strattera be taken together?

Yes, some prescribers combine them, though it isn’t a first-line approach and the evidence is limited compared with either drug alone. The usual reasons are:

  • Partial response to Concerta at the highest tolerated dose.
  • Needing symptom control in the evening or early morning without adding more stimulant late in the day, which tends to worsen sleep.
  • Moving from one to the other, when the two overlap for a few weeks while Strattera builds up.

Combining them adds their effects on heart rate and blood pressure, so these are monitored more closely. Never add one to the other on your own.

Special situations

Substance use history

If the person with ADHD, or someone in the household, has a history of substance misuse, Strattera removes the risk of the medicine being misused or passed on. It’s often the first choice in that situation.

Tics and Tourette syndrome

Stimulants were long thought to worsen tics. Newer research suggests that for most children the risk is smaller than once feared, but some individuals do see tics increase. Non-stimulants such as Strattera are a reasonable option when tics are significant or clearly worsen on a stimulant.

Anxiety alongside ADHD

Stimulants can make some anxious people feel more on edge, while others find their anxiety eases once ADHD symptoms are controlled. Strattera doesn’t have the stimulant “edge”, which is one reason it’s sometimes tried when anxiety is prominent. The response is individual.

Adults

In adults, the efficacy gap narrows. The 2018 network meta-analysis found atomoxetine and methylphenidate similarly effective on core symptoms, though amphetamines ranked highest overall. For adults, the choice often comes down to side effects (atomoxetine’s sexual and urinary effects versus a stimulant’s effects on sleep and appetite), whether all-day coverage matters, and refill practicalities.

What happens when you stop

Concerta leaves the body within a day. ADHD symptoms return as it wears off, and some people notice a “rebound” of irritability, tiredness or low mood in the late afternoon or for a few days after stopping. Most people who take normal prescribed doses can stop without a taper. Someone who has been taking high doses, or misusing the drug, can have a heavier crash with exhaustion and depression, which needs medical support. Many families take planned breaks over school holidays to let appetite and growth catch up. That’s reasonable with Concerta, but agree on it with the prescriber.

Strattera can be stopped without tapering, according to its label, and it doesn’t cause a stimulant-style crash. Because its benefit builds over weeks, it also fades gradually, and it doesn’t suit on-and-off use such as weekend or holiday breaks. Stopping and restarting means waiting weeks again for the full effect.

Who each might suit

SituationOften favours
Need for fast results (school term, exams, a new job)Concerta
Child’s first ADHD medicine with no special concernsConcerta (methylphenidate is the first-choice class for children)
Substance misuse risk in the person or householdStrattera
Need for coverage in the evening and early morningStrattera, or a combination
Significant tics, or tics worsened by a stimulantStrattera
Stimulant caused poor sleep, appetite loss or irritability that didn’t settleStrattera
Taking fluoxetine or paroxetineEither, with careful Strattera dosing
Can’t swallow tablets wholeNeither is ideal; consider sprinkle or liquid alternatives

Comparing other ADHD options? See Qelbree vs Strattera for the newer non-stimulant, Strattera vs Wellbutrin, and Vyvanse vs Focalin for other stimulants.

Practical tips

  • Give Concerta at the same time each morning. A late dose means late-evening effects and trouble sleeping.
  • Don’t judge Strattera before about six weeks at the target dose.
  • Take Strattera with food, or split the dose, if nausea or tiredness is a problem.
  • Keep Concerta locked away and count tablets, especially with teenagers in the house.
  • Ask for height, weight, pulse and blood pressure at every review, for either drug.
  • Report yellowing skin or eyes, dark urine, chest pain, fainting, or any thoughts of self-harm straight away.

Frequently asked questions

Is Concerta stronger than Strattera?

On average, in children, yes. In the largest head-to-head trial, 56% responded to Concerta versus 45% to Strattera. In adults the difference is smaller. Some people who don’t respond to Concerta do respond to Strattera, so “stronger” doesn’t mean better for everyone.

Can you take Strattera and Concerta together?

Some prescribers combine them for partial response or for evening coverage, and they overlap during a switch. It should only be done under medical supervision, with heart rate and blood pressure monitored.

How long does Strattera take to work compared with Concerta?

Concerta works within about an hour of the first dose. Strattera may show some effect in one to two weeks, but its full effect usually takes four to six weeks or more at the target dose.

Is Strattera a controlled substance?

No. Strattera is a non-stimulant with no abuse potential, so it can be refilled like an ordinary prescription. Concerta is a Schedule II controlled substance that needs a new prescription for each fill.

Can you switch from Concerta to Strattera?

Yes. Because Strattera takes weeks to work, prescribers often start it while Concerta continues, then taper Concerta once Strattera has had time to build up, to avoid a gap in symptom control.

References

Try our interactive tool: ADHD medication comparison tool

Compare stimulants and non-stimulants by duration, ages and controlled status.

About this article

Written by the Health Linear Editorial Team from primary sources such as FDA prescribing information, DailyMed, NIH and peer-reviewed studies, which are linked in the article. Last updated October 28, 2026.

Read our editorial process and medical disclaimer. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.